Hello mokuc,
How long has she now been lame? Concerning the desmopathy how much edema, fibrosis, and calcification? Has the coffin joint fluid been evaluated?
One of the problems with horses that have long established lower limb deformities (“toes in badly”) is knowing what is the best way to balance the foot so that a minimum of stress is placed on the soft tissues that support the foot including the medial collateral ligament of the coffin joint. This balance is not just with respect to the length of the toe but both anterior-posterior balance and medial-lateral balance. Right now it appears that the 3 years of soundness give us a good idea of what was a good trim for this horse. What would it take to have the horse returned to that state?
If there are some acute treatable causes of lameness they are likely to be due to inflammation secondary to the instabilities that resulted in injury (maybe exacerbated by the trimming but possibly the end stage of what has long been a worsening problem), anti-inflammatory drugs and rest are likely to help. What did the MRI folks have to say with respect to treatments?
DrO